
I watched director Ram‘s Yezhu Kadal Yezhu Malai. What can I say? What should have been a memorable film like The Man from Earth (2007) turned out to be a complete disappointment. The hero of the film was not Nivin Pauly or Soori, but a train toilet rat that got the most screen time. Mangoidiots gives it a Rotten.
Soori is returning from Dubai after eight years and boards an empty train coach on his way home. He meets a strange-looking Nivin Pauly, who says he has been living for the last 8000 years. With such an expansive backdrop, you would not be mistaken to expect something unseen in Tamil cinema.
When it began, I thought it would show the Tamil audience a new world. For the first 30 minutes, I had high hopes. Director Ram is known for giving his characters strong emotions. I wondered how he would use a tool like magical realism. Instead, we get a string of AI-like videos, and the film keeps returning to the rat. It is not even a clean rat, but a dirty one running around in a train toilet. After a few minutes, I found it disgusting to even look at.
The only good thing in the film was Soori‘s performance, and that too only in the first half. He was brilliant, especially in the opening scenes, where we could feel his tension. But the screenplay quickly loses its grip, and his efforts go in vain.
The two lead characters had to be locked together for a few hours in a life-and-death situation for one of them. For that, the director has chosen a running train with empty coaches. That part is understandable. But a better situation would have added the tension that was sorely missing here. Even on a Deepavali day, as the screenplay says, no long-distance train in Tamil Nadu will run that empty. That is where we, as the audience, lose the connection, and it was never restored.
Imagine the intensity of love that a person who has lived for 8000 years would have for his lover. Sadly, the romance between the characters played by Nivin Pauly and Anjali comes across as platonic. The irony is that we are told they have 12 kids between them. Anegan (2015) would’ve shown this kind of multiple lives beautifully.
In the second half, the movie wanders aimlessly. Thankfully, a sudden new character is introduced to force closure, though the character feels unnatural. Even as we walk out of the theatre, we are wondering who Nivin Pauly‘s character really was. He can speak English, knows current social behaviours and even the repercussions of beating policemen, and yet he does what he does.
Lastly, near the climax, by which time I had seen enough of the dirty rat, the director shows close-ups of tiny rat pups. I felt queasy just looking at them.
To sum up, Soori gave a good first half, but the screenplay let him down. The rat took over the film, and the promise of a new world for Tamil cinema was lost. It is a Rotten from Mangoidiots.
Discover more from Mangoidiots.com
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

